Estero Council of Community Leaders
Minutes of the Regular Monthly Meeting
March 18, 2005
The meeting was called to order by Chairman Eslick in the River Club of
Pelican Sound at 2:00 p.m. A quorum was present.
New attendees were acknowledged and introduced.
Minutes of the February 18, 2005 meeting, distributed before the meeting were
approved.
In the absence of Treasurer Bob Perry, Arnie Rosenthal gave the report. Total
contributions and dues to date total $2875.00. Expenses to date were $274.40,
leaving a balance of $2598.60 as of March 18, 2005. A few checks were received
at the meeting and will be reflected in the next month’s report. The treasurer’s
report was approved. The $300 amount or $1 per household from each community for
the Annexation Fund should be made out to the Thomas Hart Trust Account.
Twenty-one communities have paid their 2005 dues of $100.
Barbara Akins, Chair of the Membership Committee reported that Bob Perry will
be resigning as the Member representative of the
Vines and Chris Smith will be
replacing him. Mr. Smith was accepted.
Member and Alternate Members are still needed from
Bella Terra,
Cascades,
Covered Wagon Trailer Park,
Cranbrook Harbor, Estero Chamber of Commerce,
Estero
River Heights, Mariner’s Cove,
Meadowbrook,
Rapallo, The
Lakes of Estero, the
Reserve at Estero and
Villagio.
Bob Perry will soon be moving from the Estero community. He has been Chairing
a Committee to landscape the perimeter of Estero High School in order to hide
the chain link fence on both River Ranch and Williams roads. We will need a new
chairperson for this position.
Chris Smith has volunteered to replace Bob Perry as Treasurer. No other
nomination being made from the floor a motion was made and seconded to approve
Chris Smith as ECCL’s new Treasurer.
ECCL is still seeking a grant from the County for landscaping Sandy Lane from
Corkscrew Road to Pelican Colony Road where it will meet with US 41. The County
Roadway Landscape Advisory Committee will meet in April and ECCL will make a
presentation at that time.
This committee has met twice since last month. The “Bonita won’t annex
Estero” article in the Banner is in error. Bonita Springs is commissioning a
$10,000 study, which is required by law to try to determine what impact or what
municipal needs exist in the area that they are considering annexing. The city
Council took two steps at their last meeting:
- Voted to fund the $10,000 annexation study, and
- Reaffirmed, formally, their continuing desire to protect the two mile
buffer area.
Protection of the two mile buffer is not a new position for the City. They
have had this position for three years. Their assessment of what this two mile
buffer means is at variance with most legal authorities. We have asked our
attorney to research the legality of the two mile buffer and the history of its
waiver so frequently by local legislative delegations involved in incorporation
matters. This provision is in the incorporation law, not the annexation law. The
two mile buffer is one of the criteria that legislative delegations take into
account when communities seeking incorporation make presentations to their
legislative delegation for incorporation. There are a lot of differing opinions
among legislators whether this standard needs to be enforced. In general, it has
not been enforced by most legislative delegations in the past. Bonita is trying
to make more out of it than it is and that seems to be their posture, seemingly
thus confusing the citizens of Estero.
John Ruehl would like a list of every representative of each community. He
suggested that we keep the incorporation of Estero option available.
The annexation survey went out today to 5,320 registered voters in two
precincts that are in the annexation area under consideration by Bonita Springs.
Tabulation of results received by late March will be announced at the special
ECCL Village with a Vision presentation at the Grand Ballroom of the
Hyatt
Regency Coconut Point Resort at 9 a.m., Saturday, April 2. Volunteers will be
needed on March 29 to count the ballots…expect about 2000 ballots.
These Estero committees would likely become ineffective in areas annexed by
Bonita Springs after the annexation is completed. The two mile halo would move
to a location two miles north of the new Bonita Springs boundary after a
successful annexation. Our counsel, at our request, has prepared for us a draft
letter to go to our local legislative delegation to seek commitments from them
that, after a reasonable period of time, the residents of Estero would have the
ability to determine how they want to be governed without consideration of the
two mile buffer. At that point in time, should Estero wish to consider
incorporating, we would be able to develop an incorporation plan that would go
down to the Bonita border and retain the integrity of the Estero community.
The Annexation Review Committee will review and revise this draft at their
next meeting on Thursday. The research committee of the annexation committee has
been meeting with Tony Majul, the CFO of the county to assess the impact of any
annexation upon the County and Estero.
On April 6 Bonita City Council will approve the areas of research that the
city will study with their $10,000. The ECCL will monitor that meeting. In
addition the Annexation Review Committee has the inter-local agreement that has
been proposed by the City of Bonita Springs and discussed with the County.
Therefore, there is a lot of work to be done on this issue and hopefully, the
City will defer or delay this initiative, but at this point in time we have to
work on the assumption that they will proceed at a slightly slower pace. The
Annexation Review Committee will meet at 12:45 at
Stoneybrook next Thursday.
Need names and e-mail addresses for all Board Members from each community for
the planned community-wide Annexation Workshop.
Barbara Akins called our attention to a petition that is being circulated by
the Estero Civic Association for those people in Estero who are not registered
to vote in Florida or do not live in the area that Bonita has targeted for
annexation. This will give those residents a chance to express their feelings
about annexation. This petition is entitled “A Voice to the Voiceless”. The
Civic Association has contributed $500 toward the annexation survey costs.
The Transportation Committee has met two times in the last month to identify
all traffic issues within the community. The plan for the Estero Flyover was to
connect Three Oaks Parkway to Ben Hill Griffin Boulevard. Recent newspaper
accounts indicate that County staff want to extend the Flyover east of Ben Hill
to the proposed CR 951 route and down to Corkscrew Road at that point. A draft
of a letter to the county commissioners was read, as follows:
“Some of the members of the ECCL read in the newspaper that apparently Lee
D.O.T. has decided to extend the I-75 flyover eastward to the power lines then
southward to Corkscrew Road. To our knowledge there has never been a hearing
held regarding this matter for the residents of Estero. In our opinion nothing
as important as this should be approved to go forward without a hearing by the
County and its Commissioners. We strongly urge, in an effort to provide the
proper and legal process, to establish a hearing date and forum so that the
residents of Estero as well as Bonita Springs can be heard on this matter.”
Chairman Eslick asked that the letter be passed on to the Transportation
Committee to be included in their agenda at their Thursday meeting. Miramar
Development has agreed to work with the ECCL and the surrounding enterprises
including FGCU, the owners of
Germaine Arena, Stock Development and provide
traffic engineering services to help develop solutions for the traffic and road
problems in and around the I-75/Corkscrew Intersection. We would like to have
some solutions that we can jointly present to the county and state to resolve
these problems.
The Committee is in the process of building a coalition of private sector,
public sector and community support for solutions to our traffic problems. The
Committee’s program will be comprehensive for all of the Estero area. We will be
asking the University, developers, land-owners etc., to work on the traffic
issues with us. Nancy Keefer, the Executive Director of the Bonita Chamber, has
indicated a desire for that group to work with our Committee. As a result a
joint meeting of our Transportation Committee’s has been scheduled for April
15th.
The Wal-Mart Corporation has identified 5 store sites in the U.S. that have
roadway limitations delaying or preventing store construction. One of them is
the Estero Parkway/US 41 store site. Their lobbyist in Washington. D.C. is
working with the U. S. Senate to have an appropriation approved for these sites
this year. Two new projects on this US 41 road segment are now seeking zoning
approval from Lee County. The developers of these projects, “Estero 30” and
“Estero by the River” were notified at a recent ECPP meeting that they also need
to support this road widening. Construction of this 2.5 mile road segment is now
up to $22 million vs. $17 million last year. ECCL needs to monitor these issues
closely.
At a recent meeting sponsored by Lee Memorial Health Systems, Dennis
Merrifield reemphasized with Jim Nathan, the CEO of Lee Memorial Health Systems,
the need for more health care facilities in Estero.
The U.S. Post Office is ready to purchase 5 acres on Three Oaks from the
school district. Estero Fire Rescue has redesigned and expanded their website.
It contains three years of the Estero Development Report.
The Village with a Vision program will have its final presentation at the
Coconut Point Hyatt on Saturday, April 2. There have been 13 presentations this
year.
It was suggested that the Committee meet with County staff to see what
programs are planned for the park; determine if some of the programs might need
to stay in San Carlos Park and what other programs the Estero community would
like in the Park.
It was suggest that a letter of congratulations be sent to the State and to
Lee County from the ECCL for their successful purchase and thus preservation of
this most important property.
Gordon Lyons reported that the
Estero Medical Center has greatly improved
their design from the first presentation. The Enclave at
Rapallo design is
exceptional. Gordon was pleased to announce that Jim Wallace is joining the EDRC
committee.
“Estero 30” and “Estero by the River” were discussed. These are developments
that will have to be watched in the future particularly because they are
infringing on the Old Estero area and involve development along the Estero
River. Points were made regarding protecting these historical and environment
issues.
The Shoppes at Estero Town Center is on the southeast corner of Corkscrew and
Three Oaks. The land contains a big box parcel for a store of up to 165,000
square feet, rimmed by other stores. All the stores in the project must have
compatible architecture and landscaping. The first part of the project is two multitenant retail buildings along Three Oaks Parkway. The Mediterranean
architecture of these buildings will set the tone for the development. No
tenants are committed yet.
“Can Nature Survive our Growth” at
FGCU on April 1.
“From Runoff to Red Dust” at FGCU on March 24
Rally for David—for David Graham of the Bonita Bay Group who’s health has not
been good. Golf outings are scheduled for April 2 at Legends and May 7 at
Mediterra to benefit David and his health care costs.
The meeting was adjourned at 4:00 p.m. The next meeting will be Friday, April
15 at the Pelican Sound River Club at 2:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Faie Saunders, Secretary
|